16.3.08
The Better Analogy
I keep hearing supporters declaring that Barack Obama cannot be held accountable for his Pastor's words. The reason that is consistently cited is that one cannot be found guilty by association. I find this assertion to be ridiculous. It is not simply association.
One supporter, comedian Tracey Morgan, described it like this: If you have a friend that likes prostitutes, that does not mean that you like prostitutes or that you visit them. I find this terribly reductive and non-analogous.
The more appropriate analogy would be: You have a friend who really enjoys prostitutes. He enjoys them so much that every week he gives speeches on the laurels of prostitution. You decide to go every week to hear his speeches. You decide that what he is saying is so insightful and instructional that you should bring your wife and children to hear his speeches. Every week... for nearly twenty years... listening to speeches about how great hookers are and returning next week for more. He is so inspirational to you that you have him perform a marriage ceremony for you and your spouse and perform a baptism on your children. You hail him publicly as your "moral compass" and as a brilliant and insightful man. After years of attendance and support from you, one day you are confronted by an outsider who claims that you approve of prostitution. Hearing this you reply: "How dare you? What makes you think I approve of prostitution? That person is merely an acquaintance. You cannot find me guilty by association."
One supporter, comedian Tracey Morgan, described it like this: If you have a friend that likes prostitutes, that does not mean that you like prostitutes or that you visit them. I find this terribly reductive and non-analogous.
The more appropriate analogy would be: You have a friend who really enjoys prostitutes. He enjoys them so much that every week he gives speeches on the laurels of prostitution. You decide to go every week to hear his speeches. You decide that what he is saying is so insightful and instructional that you should bring your wife and children to hear his speeches. Every week... for nearly twenty years... listening to speeches about how great hookers are and returning next week for more. He is so inspirational to you that you have him perform a marriage ceremony for you and your spouse and perform a baptism on your children. You hail him publicly as your "moral compass" and as a brilliant and insightful man. After years of attendance and support from you, one day you are confronted by an outsider who claims that you approve of prostitution. Hearing this you reply: "How dare you? What makes you think I approve of prostitution? That person is merely an acquaintance. You cannot find me guilty by association."
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment